IP Search & Consulting

 

I. Patent Search and Patent Challenges

  • Novelty Search and Pre-R&D Search: Conduct prior art searches around proposed patent applications or R&D technologies, analyze the development status of relevant technologies, existing patent portfolios, and potential innovation space, and provide references for R&D project initiation, patent applications, and scope-of-protection design.

  • Patent Invalidation Search: Conduct invalidation searches against patents in litigation, competitors’ core patents, or other target patents; systematically search patent documents, papers, technical materials, product materials, and other prior public evidence; and design search directions, timelines, and evidence combinations based on patent invalidation and litigation experience.

  • Patent Stability Analysis: Analyze stability issues of target patents, such as novelty, inventiveness, sufficient disclosure, and amendments beyond the original scope, based on prior art, prosecution files, claim amendments, family prosecution history, and relevant legal provisions.

  • Third-Party Observations and Patent Challenges: For key patent applications of competitors still under examination, submit third-party observations or other procedural responses through searches and legal analysis, reducing the possibility that relevant patents become market barriers.

  • Patent Legal and Other Information Searches: Conduct specialized information investigations as needed, including patent families, legal status, citation relationships, applicants, inventors, assignments, licenses, pledges, litigation, and administrative proceedings.

  • Patent Litigation Search Support: Conduct targeted searches around specific disputed issues in patent infringement litigation, patent invalidation, and administrative litigation, supporting litigation strategy, evidence organization, and determinations of patent validity/stability.

II. FTO Freedom to Operate and Patent Infringement Risk Analysis

  • Product FTO Freedom to Operate Due Diligence: Around specific products to be developed, manufactured, sold, offered for sale, or exported, systematically investigate valid and potentially valid patents in target countries or regions, and identify third-party patent rights that may affect product implementation and commercialization.

  • Overseas Patent Infringement Risk Screening: Based on the client’s target markets, conduct specialized patent risk investigations in the United States, Europe, Japan, South Korea, and other key countries or regions, focusing on territorial validity, term of protection, legal status, family portfolios, and differences in local systems.

  • Claim Infringement Comparison: Further read the claims, specifications, and necessary prosecution files of key patents identified in preliminary screening, compare technical features against the product’s technical solution, and analyze potential infringement risks and arguable space.

  • Risk Grading and Handling Paths: Grade key patents based on factors such as scope of rights, degree of technical overlap, legal status, stability, rights holder situation, and commercial impact, and propose response paths for medium- and high-risk patents, including design-around, invalidation or stability analysis, third-party observations, licensing negotiations, cross-licensing, competitive portfolio planning, or continuous monitoring.

  • Early Intervention at the R&D Stage: For projects with long cycles or large R&D investments, FTO and patent risk screening can be moved forward to the solution design and product development stages, so that search results are fed back into R&D iterations in a timely manner, reducing later redesign and market entry costs.

III. Intellectual Property Due Diligence

  • IP Due Diligence for Investment and Financing: For corporate investment and financing activities, conduct systematic investigations from dimensions such as IP ownership, legal status, stability, infringement risk, IP assets, strength of protection, and the relevance of IP to the main business.

  • IP Due Diligence for M&A and Restructuring: Around the target company’s core technologies, patent portfolios, IP ownership, licensing encumbrances, and potential disputes, analyze implementation risks, transaction risks, and management risks that may arise during the transaction.

  • IP Transaction Risk Investigation: For transactions such as patent licensing, technology transfer, patent assignment, IP contribution as equity, and pledge financing, investigate the ownership, validity, scope of protection, stability, technological advancement, and potential disputes of the target IP.

  • Special Patent Due Diligence: For key technologies such as innovative drugs, core equipment, and key components, conduct special investigations into core patents regarding ownership, scope of protection, stability, patent families, competing patents, and freedom to operate.

  • Defensive and Offensive Due Diligence: According to the client’s role in the transaction and commercial objectives, distinguish scenarios such as seller self-check, buyer due diligence, investor due diligence, and reverse due diligence, and determine investigation priorities, risk tolerance, and result presentation methods.

IV. Patent Information Analysis, Patent Navigation, and Competitive Intelligence

  • Patent Navigation: Combine patent information with industry status, policy environment, market competition, and corporate R&D activities; analyze technology development paths, industrial competitive landscapes, and future technology opportunities; and provide references for industrial or corporate R&D decisions.

  • Patent Early Warning: Continuously collect and analyze patents and market information in relevant fields, identify competitor movements and potential infringement risks, and formulate risk response plans based on corporate products and target markets.

  • Competitor Patent Monitoring: Around key competitors and affiliated companies, continuously track newly published patents, patent families, divisional and continuation applications, key inventors, technical topics, and legal events.

  • Technology Development Trends and Hotspot Analysis: Analyze technology life cycles, R&D hotspots, technology gaps, and potential alternative routes through dimensions such as filing trends, technical classifications, applicants, geographical portfolios, family sizes, citations, and technical relevance.

  • Patent Portfolio and Competitive Position Analysis: Analyze the patent portfolios of the enterprise itself or competitors from dimensions such as technical coverage, portfolio depth, geographical layout, stability, commercial relevance, and competitive entities, providing a basis for patent asset management and competitive strategy.

  • Research Team and Technological Advancement Analysis: Around research institutions, R&D teams, or technologies to be invested in, analyze their R&D capabilities and industrialization potential through indicators such as patent quality, technology accumulation, key inventors, R&D continuity, and competitive position.

V. Patent Mining and Strategic Portfolio Planning

  • High-Value Patent Mining: In conjunction with the R&D process, conduct patent mining for core technologies, key improvements, and technical solutions with potential market value, and reasonably determine protection boundaries through prior searches.

  • Corporate Patent System Portfolio Planning: Form a layered patent portfolio around core products, key components, technology routes, and future R&D directions, enhancing the strength of protection for core technologies and business models.

  • Competitive and Strategic Patent Portfolio Planning: In light of competitors’ products and patents, identify technically valuable points and form market competition leverage through blocking, surrounding, alternative, or forward-looking portfolio planning.

  • Design-Around and Further Innovation: For competitors’ core patents, seek alternative technical paths through claim analysis and prior art searches, reducing infringement risks while developing new independent intellectual property.

  • Global Patent Portfolio Planning: Formulate strategies for filing countries, filing routes, priority, and patent portfolios based on product export regions, corporate market planning, R&D pace, and major competitors’ global portfolios.

VI. Intellectual Property Consulting for IPOs

  • IP System Diagnosis and Rectification: Comprehensively inventory corporate patents, trademarks, copyrights, trade secrets, and other IP assets; assess the match between portfolio planning and business development; identify hidden risks such as ownership defects, portfolio gaps, and lapse due to failure to maintain; issue targeted rectification plans; and assist in establishing and improving IP management systems to achieve standardized full-process management from R&D to application, maintenance, and utilization.

  • Core Technology Ownership Review and Compliance Argumentation: Review the correspondence between core technologies and patents; verify ownership of employee inventions, commissioned development, and joint development; demonstrate the legality of core technology sources; investigate potential disputes involving former employers’ trade secrets and university employee achievements; and ensure that core technologies are independent and complete, eliminating IP dependence on controlling shareholders and affiliates.

  • Sci-Tech Innovation Attribute Argumentation and Professional Responses to Review Inquiries: Assist in organizing materials corresponding to R&D projects, patents, and R&D expenses to meet quantitative indicators for sci-tech innovation attributes; support the drafting and disclosure of IP content in sections such as “Business and Technology” and “Risk Factors” in the prospectus; professionally respond to stock exchange inquiries regarding core technology advancement, patent ownership, and litigation disputes; and coordinate the issuance of special verification opinions.

  • Infringement Risk Screening and Litigation Blocking Defense: Conduct Freedom to Operate (FTO) analysis for main products to identify infringement risks in advance; establish competitor patent monitoring and early warning mechanisms to prevent malicious litigation and patent invalidation blocking during the sensitive period of listing; and formulate comprehensive contingency plans for litigation response, invalidation, and counter-negotiation to minimize the impact of IP disputes on the listing process.

VII. Intellectual Property Consulting for Investment, Financing, and Major Commercial Activities

  • Intellectual Property Due Diligence: Comprehensively verify the ownership status, registration, and annuity maintenance of the target company’s patents, trademarks, copyrights, and other assets; investigate rights defects and potential disputes such as IP pledges, freezing, litigation, and invalidation; verify compliance matters such as technology import/export control, open-source software compliance, and data source legality; and issue professional due diligence reports and risk lists to provide a reliable basis for investment decisions.

  • Valuation of Patents, Trademarks, and Other Intangible Assets: Assist in assessing the relevance of core IP to the main business and core technologies and its commercialization contribution; analyze remaining patent terms, family portfolios, and technology life cycles; identify filler patents and valuation bubbles; and provide quantitative references for pre-investment valuation negotiations and capital contribution at appraised value.

  • IP Arrangements in Transaction Terms and Valuation Negotiation Support: Design transaction structures such as IP contribution as equity and exclusive/non-exclusive licensing; draft IP representations and warranties, defect indemnity, and price adjustment clauses in investment agreements; design valuation adjustment mechanism (VAM) and earn-out arrangements based on indicators such as the number of patent applications and the subsistence of core patents; and participate in negotiations throughout to maximize IP rights and interests in the transaction.

  • IP Transfer and Licensing Scheme Design in M&A and Restructuring: Formulate overall plans for the transfer of trademarks, patents, domain names, and trade secrets along with the business; design flexible arrangements such as retained asset licenses and transitional licenses; properly handle ownership succession issues for employee inventions as personnel move; and ensure smooth business operations after restructuring.

  • Clause Design and Risk Prevention in Technology Cooperation and Licensing Transactions: Design clauses on licensing scope, territory, term, sublicensing, and ownership of improvements; arrange IP ownership and revenue-sharing mechanisms for joint R&D and commissioned development; and conduct Freedom to Operate (FTO) analysis to prevent and control infringement risks in technology implementation.

  • Overseas IP Portfolio Planning and Cross-Border Transaction Compliance Support: Formulate international patent and trademark portfolio plans for target markets to prevent overseas squatting risks; provide coordinated consulting on IP, export control, and data compliance in cross-border technology transactions; and assist in responding to overseas IP disputes to safeguard international operations.

Typical Service Scenarios

R&D and Innovation Stage
Before R&D project initiation, through technology novelty searches, patent landscapes, competitor analysis, and technology gap identification, help R&D teams understand existing technology boundaries, reduce duplicate R&D, and provide information support for technology routes and subsequent patent portfolio planning. During R&D, continuous searches and FTO early warning can be carried out in conjunction with phased solutions, enabling patent risks to be fed back to product design as early as possible.

Product Launch and Overseas Market Entry
Conduct FTO and competing patent screening around products to be launched and target countries, identify potential blocking rights, carry out claim, prosecution history, legal status, and stability analysis on key patents, and form risk levels and next-step handling recommendations.

Patent Disputes and Competitive Offense and Defense
When receiving a cease-and-desist letter, encountering infringement litigation, or needing to proactively initiate competitive patent actions, provide support for litigation, invalidation, settlement negotiations, or market competition through invalidation searches, evidence chain construction, family prosecution history research, infringement/non-infringement analysis, and third-party observations.

Investment, Financing, M&A, and IPO
Conduct due diligence around core IP ownership, validity, scope of protection, freedom to operate, and commercial relevance, and adjust the investigation scope, priorities, and risk presentation methods according to the different roles of investors, acquirers, financing parties, or IPO-bound enterprises.

Project Implementation and Quality Control

Major search and analysis projects usually consist of multiple stages, including technical understanding, searching, screening, legal analysis, and strategic recommendations. To improve search comprehensiveness, analytical consistency, and result reviewability, Rayto establishes standardized workflows according to project type, with coordinated participation by search personnel, patent agents, and lawyers.

Step 1 | Clarify Objectives and Decompose Technology
Through project kick-off meetings, technical materials, product materials, and R&D personnel interviews, clarify the purpose of the investigation, product boundaries, target regions, timelines, and key competitors; decompose the entire machine or complex technology into searchable and indexable technical topics.

Step 2 | Develop Search Strategy and Conduct Comprehensive Search
Develop search strategies integrating keywords, classification numbers, key applicants, related entities, inventors, patent families, citations, and non-patent literature, and retain reviewable search formulas and search records.

Step 3 | Technical Indexing and Preliminary Screening Review
Conduct preliminary screening of results based on unified technical tags and screening criteria; for important projects, back-to-back review or cross-review may be adopted to reduce missed screening and misjudgment.

Step 4 | Refined Screening of Key Patents and Legal Analysis
For key patents, read the claims, specifications, and necessary prosecution files; verify legal status, patent families, and territorial effect; and determine the rights that may truly affect the client’s technology or transaction.

Step 5 | Risk Grading and Evidence Assessment
Grade risks based on technical overlap, scope of rights, stability, legal status, rights holder situation, and commercial impact; for invalidation or stability projects, simultaneously assess evidence publication dates, technical relevance, and combination logic.

Step 6 | Formulate Actionable Response Recommendations
According to project objectives, propose follow-up measures such as design-around, invalidation reserve, third-party observations, licensing negotiations, cross-licensing, competitive portfolio planning, adjustment of transaction terms, or continuous monitoring, and distinguish short-term actions from medium- and long-term strategies.

Step 7 | Dynamic Updates and Continuous Monitoring
For projects with long R&D cycles, continuous product iterations, or fierce competition, establish topic-specific databases and regular update mechanisms to continuously track newly published patents, legal status, and competitor movements.

Typical Deliverables

Depending on the project type and the client’s internal use scenarios, project results can be presented in different forms, such as reports, databases, comparison tables, maps, or management briefs. For major projects, it is recommended to balance both “reviewability” and “management readability.” Common deliverables include:

  • Project technology decomposition and technical tagging system;

  • Search strategy, search formulas, search records, and descriptions of key databases;

  • Patent family, legal status, and territorial validity lists;

  • Patent screening database with item-by-item inclusion/exclusion rationale;

  • Schematic of the scope of protection of key patent claims and technical feature comparison tables;

  • High-, medium-, and low-risk patent matrix and management summary;

  • Patent stability/invalidation evidence list, evidence chain, and combination analysis;

  • Competitor technology routes, patent portfolios, and technology gap maps;

  • Recommendations for design-around, patent challenges, licensing negotiations, competitive portfolio planning, and continuous monitoring;

  • Special reports for R&D, legal, or management.

Key Industries Covered

The team has long carried out search and consulting services around the technical characteristics and IP risk features of different industries, and allocates lawyers, patent agents, and search analysts with corresponding technical backgrounds according to project needs. Existing business experience mainly covers:

Electronic Information and Software: Internet, software, communications, smart terminals, digital technology

Intelligent Manufacturing and Robotics: Robotics, automation equipment, control systems, industrial equipment

Consumer Goods and Smart Home: Home appliances, cleaning tools, smart home, consumer electronics

Semiconductors and Integrated Circuits: Semiconductor devices, sensors, integrated circuits, photovoltaics

New Energy and Automotive: Power batteries, new energy vehicles, auto parts, energy equipment

Biomedicine and Medical Devices: Innovative drugs, biotechnology, diagnostics, medical equipment

Chemicals and New Materials: Fine chemicals, composite materials, functional materials, environmental technology

Other Segmented Industries: Lighting, machinery, environmental protection, and other specialized technical fields

Cross-Industry Comprehensive Projects: Investment and financing, IPO, industrial navigation, and corporate competitive intelligence

Selected Representative Cases and Service Experience

I. Patent Search and Patent Challenges

  • “Spin Mop” Core Patent Invalidation Case: The relevant core patent had previously been maintained valid after multiple invalidation proceedings. Rayto conducted new searches, discovered important evidence, and proposed new invalidation arguments, ultimately resulting in the patent being declared wholly invalid. Existing materials record that the related first-instance litigation awarded RMB 6 million in damages.

  • Kubota Rice Transplanter Series Patent Invalidation Case: A new search strategy was designed for core patents that had already undergone multiple invalidation proceedings. Important evidence, including multiple reference books from the 1970s, was discovered, supporting subsequent patent invalidation and litigation. The amount in dispute in the related litigation was approximately RMB 40 million.

  • Smart Blackboard Series Core Patent Invalidation Case: Where the relevant core patents had already undergone multiple invalidation proceedings, the team conducted new searches and discovered important evidence, filed invalidation actions against the relevant patents, and supported the client’s patent litigation and market operations.

  • Medical Device Third-Party Observation Project: Through patent information searches, potential risks were identified in a competitor’s core patent application. Third-party observations were submitted against the relevant patent, reducing in advance the risk of the competing patent becoming a market barrier.

II. FTO and Overseas Patent Risk Investigations

  • New Energy Strategic Metals Series Patent Analysis Project. Guangdong Brunp Recycling Technology Co., Ltd., Sep 2022–Apr 2023; completed.

  • FTO Due Diligence for a Semiconductor Photovoltaic Cell Structure in China (CN) and Japan (JP). Tongwei Solar Co., Ltd., Sep 2021–Feb 2022.

  • FTO Due Diligence for Solar Cell Structures in South Korea (KR), India (IN), and Türkiye (TR). Tongwei Solar Co., Ltd., Sep 2021–Feb 2022.

  • Freedom to Operate Due Diligence for Photovoltaic Inverters in the United States (US) and Germany (EPO+DE). Sungrow Power Supply Co., Ltd., Sep 2022–Dec 2022.

  • Joint Robot Industry Patent Analysis Popularization and Promotion Project. CNIPA, Dec 2017–Jan 2018; completed (published, Volume 60).

  • Series Risk Investigation of Major Competitors in Semiconductor Mask Equipment. A certain Nanjing semiconductor technology company, Jul 2021–Jun 2023.

  • XX Series Technology Patent Right Analysis Report. XX Textile Machinery Company, Oct 2020; completed.

  • FTO Due Diligence for a Cosmetic Raw Material in Mainland China/Europe (EPO)/Japan. A certain Hubei fine chemicals company, Sep 2020; ongoing.

  • Patent Due Diligence for ZM3326E New Chemical Entity Drug. XX Investment Company, Aug 2020; completed.

  • FTO Due Diligence for High-Solid-Content Waterborne Dispersion Adhesive. A certain Ma’anshan company, Jun 2020; completed.

  • IP Strategy Consulting for Sci-Tech Innovation IPO. Zhejiang Risheng Intelligent Technology Co., Ltd., Sep 2020; completed.

  • Patent Right Due Diligence for a New Chemical Entity Drug for Treating Hyperuricemia. XX Investment Company, Mar 2020; completed.

  • Patent Right Due Diligence for a 3D Multilayer High-Throughput Organ-on-a-Chip. A certain Beijing technology company, Aug 2019; completed.

  • FTO Due Diligence for a New Energy Vehicle Suspension Assembly. A certain Wuhu automobile company, Apr 2023–Jun 2023.

  • Patent Stability Analysis and Portfolio Recommendations for a Semiconductor Device. Changzhou Zerun Co., Ltd., Jan 2024–Apr 2024.

  • FTO Due Diligence for a GPR Antagonist-Related New Chemical Entity Drug. A certain Shanghai innovative drug company, May 2024–present (currently in Phase I clinical trials in Mainland China).

  • Financing Due Diligence for AR882 New Chemical Entity Drug. Linghang Xinjie Investment Company, Dec 2019–Jun 2022 (global Phase III clinical trials).

  • Patent Technology Advancement Analysis Report for XX Research Team. Nanjing University, Jul 2019; completed.

  • Patent Infringement Risk Analysis Report for Coupling Products in the Jakarta-Bandung High-Speed Railway Project in Indonesia. A certain Guangzhou technology company, Sep 2018; completed.

  • Patent Invalidation Search Project for Modular Smart Blackboard. Nanjing Oudi Technology Co., Ltd., Oct 2018; completed.

  • Patent Invalidation Search Project for Kubota Rice Transplanter. Suzhou Jiufu Agricultural Machinery Co., Ltd., Jan 2017; completed.

  • CAR-T Cell Immunotherapy Analysis and Evaluation Project. Shanghai Sidansai Biotechnology Co., Ltd., Sep 2017–Oct 2017; completed.

  • Review of a Drug Patent Implementation License Contract Between a Well-Known Domestic Research Institute and XXX Enterprise.

  • Patent Portfolio Planning for Palbociclib Drug Series.

  • Patent Right Due Diligence for FH367-C New Chemical Entity Drug.

  • Patent Right Due Diligence for ZM326E New Chemical Entity Drug.

  • Analysis and Evaluation Project for a Contact Unit of Switchgear. Nanjing Dacheng Electric Research Institute Co., Ltd., Aug 2017–Sep 2017; completed.

III. Patent Information Analysis and Competitive Intelligence

  • New Energy Strategic Metals Series Patent Analysis Project: Conducted patent technology and industrial competition analysis around strategic metals related to the new energy industry.

  • Joint Robot Industry Patent Analysis Project: Participated in a CNIPA patent analysis popularization and promotion project, conducting systematic patent analysis around the joint robot industry.

  • Risk Investigation of Major Competitors of a Semiconductor Enterprise: Conducted continuous patent risk investigation and competitive intelligence tracking around key competitors in semiconductor mask equipment.

IV. IPO and Investment/Financing Intellectual Property Services

  • IP Consulting for a Smart Manufacturing Enterprise’s STAR Market Listing: During the IPO process, the enterprise encountered patent litigation. The team carried out a series of patent invalidation and IP risk response actions around the patents in litigation, assisting the enterprise in responding to the disputes and advancing the listing process.

  • IP Due Diligence for Multiple Innovative Drug Investment and Financing Projects: Provided special IP analysis for investment decisions around core drug patent ownership, stability, freedom to operate, and market competition risks.

  • Special Investigation of IP Licensing and Technology Transactions: Conducted special assessments of IP assets to be licensed or transacted based on patent ownership, stability, technological advancement, scope of protection, and transaction purpose.

Contact Us

When facing complex patent issues, one can start with an effective search and structured analysis. Whether a new product is about to enter the market, an enterprise is encountering a patent dispute, or there is a need to evaluate competitors, major investment projects, or future technology portfolios, the Search & Consulting Division of Rayto can start from specific technical and commercial issues and assist clients in determining suitable search, analysis, and IP response solutions.